18 months
of movement history in the Inventory Ledger Detailed View
13
columns in the FBA Returns Report, and one of them decides the money
$0.08
average FBA fee increase per unit sold, effective January 15, 2026
Key takeaways
- The return reason your buyer picked and the disposition Amazon records are different columns, and only the second one decides the money.
- The FBA Returns Report carries detailed-disposition and updates daily; the Inventory Ledger Detailed View keeps movements for 18 months.
- A unit graded unsellable is often intact inside a damaged box, which is why the grade is worth disputing with the order ID and the FNSKU.
- Getting an unfulfillable unit back needs a removal order, and FBA fees rise an average of $0.08 per unit from January 15, 2026.
- Anything a forum thread says and no Amazon page confirms is what other sellers report, not the procedure.
Before you start
- Access to the FBA reports in Seller Central, specifically the FBA Returns Report and the Inventory Ledger.
- The order ID or the FNSKU of the unit you are disputing.
- The date the return was received, so you know which claim window applies.
- A photo of the unit and its outer packaging if it already came back on a removal order.
Step by step
- Download the FBA Returns Report for the return dateAmazon's developer documentation calls it the FBA Returns Report, report type GET_FBA_FULFILLMENT_CUSTOMER_RETURNS_DATA. It is a tab delimited file of customer returned items received at a fulfilment centre, and its content updates daily. Find the row that matches your order ID.
- Read the detailed-disposition column, not the return reasonThe report carries return-date, order-id, sku, asin, fnsku, product-name, quantity, fulfillment-center-id, detailed-disposition, reason, status, license-plate-number and customer-comments. The dropdown your buyer picked sits in reason and decides nothing. What decides whether the unit can be sold again is detailed-disposition.
- Confirm where the unit landed in the Inventory Ledger Detailed ViewThe Detailed View carries a Disposition field and a CustomerReturns event type, and keeps every historical movement for 18 months. Use it to see whether the unit went back into sellable stock or into unfulfillable stock waiting for a removal or disposal order.
- Separate packaging damage from product damageSellers on the Amazon Seller Forums report that a unit graded damaged is often intact inside a damaged box. Amazon also repackages some returns automatically, and a moderated forum thread on FBA repackaging states that the service is automatic for eligible items and cannot be disabled. If your item was eligible and still ended up unfulfillable, that is the fact to put in the case.
- Open one case with transaction level evidenceQuote the order ID, the FNSKU, the return date and the exact value in detailed-disposition, and state why the grade does not match the unit. What other sellers report is that the first answers are template answers, so keep the case ID and reply on the same case rather than opening a new one.
- Price the removal before you order itAn unfulfillable unit only leaves the warehouse on a removal or a disposal order, and both cost money per unit. Amazon says FBA fees rise by an average of $0.08 per unit sold in 2026, that there are no new FBA fee types, and that unless otherwise noted the changes take effect on January 15, 2026. Compare the removal fee for your size tier against what the unit is worth.
Amazon graded my return unsellable, and the unit is fine. That is the sentence, and it is not a complaint about packaging: it is a decision about money. The refund already left your account. What is still open is the grade Amazon put on the unit when it arrived back at the fulfilment centre, because that grade, and not the condition of the product, decides whether the unit goes back on sale, sits in unfulfillable stock, or becomes your loss.
This is a different problem from a genuinely broken return. If the customer really damaged the unit, the policy answer on customer damaged FBA returns is the one you need. This article is about the case where the grade and the unit do not match.
What the grade is, and where it lives
Amazon records what happened to a returned unit in a field its own developer documentation calls detailed-disposition. It sits in the FBA Returns Report, report type GET_FBA_FULFILLMENT_CUSTOMER_RETURNS_DATA, a tab delimited file of customer returned items received at a fulfilment centre whose content updates daily.
The report carries thirteen columns: return-date, order-id, sku, asin, fnsku, product-name, quantity, fulfillment-center-id, detailed-disposition, reason, status, license-plate-number and customer-comments.
Two of those columns look like the same thing and are not. reason is the dropdown your buyer picked when they started the return. detailed-disposition is what an Amazon associate recorded after looking at the unit. The first one decides nothing. The second one decides everything, and it is the only one worth disputing.
Why a good unit gets graded unsellable
Three mechanisms, and they stack.
The box, not the product. A unit arrives with an opened or crushed outer carton and gets graded accordingly, even though the product inside is untouched. Sellers on the Amazon Seller Forums report exactly this pattern in a thread on customer damaged grades with 902 views and 27 replies, and in another on returns marked defective that still land back in inventory with 243 views. One seller on X posted a photo of a return graded damaged that was brand new in the box.
Automatic repackaging covers some of it, not all. Amazon does repackage some returns so they can be resold as new. A moderated forum thread on FBA repackaging states that "this service is automatic for eligible items and can't be disabled." If your product type is eligible and the unit still ended up unfulfillable, that gap is the fact to put in your case.
Grading is a judgement made at speed. None of the above is a conspiracy. A fulfilment centre processes returns in volume, and a fast grade errs toward unsellable because that is the safer error for Amazon. It is the expensive error for you.
How to check the disposition of an FBA return, step by step
The steps are in the pasos block of this article. The short version: pull the FBA Returns Report for the return date, read detailed-disposition rather than reason, confirm where the unit landed in the Inventory Ledger Detailed View, and build the case around the order ID, the FNSKU and that one field.
The Inventory Ledger Detailed View is the part most sellers skip. It carries a Disposition field and a CustomerReturns event type, and it keeps every historical movement for 18 months. That is your evidence window: the unit's whole path is recorded, so you do not have to argue from memory.
What happens if the grade sticks
An unfulfillable unit does not leave a fulfilment centre on its own. It leaves on a removal order or a disposal order, and both cost money per unit. That cost is the reason the grade matters even when the product is perfect: you are choosing between paying to get a good unit back and letting Amazon dispose of it.
Price that choice with current numbers. For 2026, Amazon announced that "FBA fees will increase by an average of $0.08 per unit sold", that there will be no new FBA fee types, and that unless otherwise noted the changes are effective January 15, 2026, with at least 90 days of notice. Read the removal rate for your size tier before you order, not after.
The common mistakes
- Arguing the return reason. The buyer's dropdown is not the decision. Quote
detailed-disposition. - Filing without the transaction level detail. Order ID, FNSKU, return date, and the exact value in that field. A case without them reads as a complaint.
- Opening a new case for every reply. What other sellers report is that the first responses are template responses. Keep the case ID and reply on the same case.
- Waiting. Claim windows exist and they are per claim type. If you do not know which window applies to a given event, our map of every FBA reimbursement claim window lists them.
- Accepting the valuation without checking it. A grade dispute and a value dispute are two different arguments. If the grade is right and the money is wrong, the article on reimbursements paid below what the product is worth is the one to read.
How to stop it from happening quietly
The failure mode is not the occasional misgraded unit. It is that nobody looks. A refund posts, the unit never comes back to sellable stock, and the loss disappears into a monthly total.
Make the FBA Returns Report a weekly habit rather than a forensic tool. Filter on detailed-disposition and compare the count of unsellable grades against your own return rate for that SKU. If one ASIN produces unsellable grades at several times the rate of the rest of your catalogue, that is either a packaging problem you can fix or a grading pattern worth a case. Both are worth more than the single unit you started with. Where to find each returns view in Seller Central is covered in how to see your FBA returns.
โThis service is automatic for eligible items and can't be disabled.โ
Amazon Seller Forums
Sources
- SP-API: Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) Reports developer-docs.amazon.com
- Amazon Selling Partners: 2026 Amazon Referral & FBA Fee Updates sellingpartners.aboutamazon.com
- Amazon Seller Forums: "Customer damaged" returns sellercentral.amazon.com
- Amazon Seller Forums: FBA Returns - Defective/Damaged but still returned to inventory? sellercentral.amazon.com
- Amazon Seller Forums: FBA Repackaging After Returns sellercentral.amazon.com
